Author Archives Laura Arnold

IURC Approves CPCN Order for IPL to Build Eagle Valley CCGT plant near Martinsville; Download and read the order

Posted by Laura Arnold  /   May 14, 2014  /   Posted in Uncategorized  /   No Comments

The Indiana Utility Regulatory Commission (IURC) just issued its order in the IPL CPCN case in Cause No. 44339 this afternoon. In a very brief cursory review of the order, it looks like IPL got everything it was asking for from the IURC.

More later after a careful read of the order.

The ordering paragraphs are as follows

IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED BY THE INDIANA UTILITY REGULATORY COMMISSION that: 

  1. IPL shall be and hereby is issued a CPCN under Chapter 8.5 to construct a CCGT ranging from approximately 644-685 MW at Eagle Valley Station. This Order constitutes the Certificate.
  2.  IPL's estimated total cost of the Eagle Valley CCGT in the amount of $631 million (minus confidential gas lateral costs) (not including AFUDC) is approved as set forth herein.
  3.  IPL is issued a CPCN under Chapter 8.5 to construct the Harding Street 5 & 6 Refueling. This Order constitutes the Certificate. 
  4. IPL's estimated cost of the Harding Street 5 & 6 Refueling Project in the amount of$36 million (not including AFUDC) is approved as set forth herein. 
  5. IPL's request for ongoing review of the Eagle Valley CCGT and Harding Street 5 & 6 Refueling Projects is approved as set forth herein. IPL shall file the ongoing reports as set forth in Para. 6(B)(ii)(e) for the purpose of ongoing review in accordance with Ind. Code § 8-1-8.5-6.  
  6. IPL is authorized to continue the accrual of AFUDC (both debt and equity) and to defer the accrual of depreciation expense on both Projects from the Project's in-service date(s) until the date of a Commission order authorizing recovery of a return and including depreciation expense thereon in IPL' s recoverable operating expenses. 
  7. IPL is authorized to record such post-in-service AFUDC (both debt and equity) and deferred depreciation as regulatory assets in Account 182.3 Other Regulatory Assets. 
  8. The Confidential Information filed under seal in this Cause shall continue to be treated by the Commission as confidential and not subject to public disclosure. 
  9. This Order shall be effective on and after the date of its approval.

ATTERHOLT, MAYS, STEPHAN, WEBER, AND ZIEGNER CONCUR:
APPROVED: May 142014

Download the order HERE> http://www.in.gov/iurc/files/44339order_051414.pdf 

Here is IPL's Press release on the order:

IPL’s plans to build state-of-the-art natural gas plant move ahead

Power plant will be one of the cleanest, most efficient in Indiana

May 14, 2014

Indianapolis — Indianapolis Power & Light Company (IPL) announced today the Indiana Utility Regulatory Commission (IURC) has approved the utility’s request for a Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity (CPCN) so IPL can invest approximately $600 million into a new combined-cycle gas turbine (CCGT) power station near Martinsville and $36 million to convert Units 5 and 6 at the Harding Street Generation Station from coal to natural gas.

“We are pleased that the IURC approved IPL’s plans as the most cost-effective and reliable solution to replace generation that will retire as a result of increasing environmental regulations,” said IPL President and CEO Kelly Huntington.  “Building a CCGT and refueling two of our Harding Street units will ensure our ability to meet the future needs of our customers and diversify our generation portfolio.  In 2017, IPL’s reliance on coal-fired generation will have decreased to only 54% from nearly 80% ten years before, with natural gas, wind, solar and oil powering the rest of our customers’ needs.”

The new natural gas plant will generate about 650 megawatts of electricity more efficiently and with fewer environmental emissions.  The CCGT will reduce the rate of sulfur dioxide (SO2), nitrogen oxide (NOx) and particulate matter emissions by more than 98 percent as compared to the retiring Eagle Valley units. Virtually all mercury, lead and fluoride emissions will be eliminated, and water use will be reduced by 97 percent.

Plans are also underway to convert Harding Street Generating Units 5 and 6, totaling approximately 200 MW, from burning coal to utilizing natural gas to create electricity. “We are working to balance costs associated with meeting new environmental standards set by the EPA and the affordability for our customers,” said Huntington. “IPL continues to offer our wide variety of programs to help customers manage their electric bills by using energy more wisely.”

The CCGT will be located in Morgan County at IPL’s Eagle Valley Generating Station, five miles north of Martinsville. Building the power plant in Martinsville provides a number of benefits to the community, including 660 construction jobs and 25 permanent positions at the new plant. Once complete, the project will bring about $1.6 million per year into Morgan County through local tax revenue.  The overall economic benefit to the state during construction is more than $857 million and another $48 million per year during operation.

Construction on the CCGT will begin this summer with a completion date in 2017.  The conversion of Harding Street Units 5 and 6 will begin in the fall 2015 and will be complete by early 2016.

Those interested in learning more about the project are invited to visit www.IPLpower.com/generation.  Questions about the project can be sent to IPLanswers@aes.com.

###

About Indianapolis Power & Light Company (IPL): Indianapolis Power & Light Company provides retail electric service to more than 470,000 residential, commercial and industrial customers in Indianapolis, as well as portions of other Central Indiana communities surrounding Marion County. During its long history, IPL has supplied its customers with some of the lowest-cost, most reliable power in the country. For more information about the company, please visit www.IPLpower.com or connect with us at www.twitter.com/IPLpowerwww.facebook.com/IPLpower or www.linkedin.com/company/IPLpower.

 

Media Contact:
Brandi Davis-Handy
Indianapolis Power & Light Company
317.261.8423, pager 317.393.7584
Brandi.DavisHandy@AES.com

BACKGROUND

Indianapolis Power and Light (IPL) filed a petition with the Indiana Utility Regulatory Commission (IURC) on April 29, 2013 for a certificate public convenience and necessity (CPCN) for the construction of a combined cycle gas turbine generation facility as well as approval to convert coal fired generating facilities to natural gas.

IPL requested a CPCN to construct a 550-725 MW CCGT at IPL's Eagle Valley Generating Station in Morgan County, Indiana. IPL was also seeking permission to convert Generating Units 5 and 6 at the Harding Street Station located in Marion County, Indiana, to natural gas.

According to IPL's petition, IPL's 2011 Integrated Resource Plan (IRP) showed that IPL may require additional generating capacity of approximately 744 MW by 2016 growing to 797 MW by 2020.

IPL requested the IURC to grant certificates of public convenience and necessity (CPCN) for the construction of the Eagle Valley CCGT plant near Martinsville as well as the Harding Street Refueling.

 

ILSR John Farrell: “Even though sunshine is free, no kind of solar power is a free lunch.”

Posted by Laura Arnold  /   May 14, 2014  /   Posted in solar  /   No Comments

The High Cost of the Solar Middleman

 John Farrell 

May 13, 2014  |  4 Comments

John

If there’s no such thing as a free lunch, then how can Americans get solar on their roof with “zero money down” and lower their electric bill?  Solar leasing, as it’s often called, is a clever market solution to poor federal and state policy design that otherwise requires Americans to do financial acrobatics to power their home or business with solar.

But solar leasing adds significantly to the cost of solar energy.

Data from the Massachusetts Department of Energy Resources published last year suggests that state taxpayers that will pay (a lot) more to make solar easy to install for individuals and businesses, and to make solar energy lucrative for solar leasing companies.

The report estimates the necessary production based incentive (in dollars per megawatt-hour of electricity produced) to support the development of solar. Specifically, the researchers priced a “10-year levelized incentive…that allows system owners to achieve their target economic rate of return.” The analysis notably focused on ownership structures, either 3rd party ownership (solar leasing) or host ownership (owned by the home or business owner).  The following chart shows the difference in state incentives necessary to support a small-scale (15-kW or less) solar array that is either owned by a 3rd party or the actual electric customer.

host v 3rd party ownership solar incentive mass

The bottom line is that leased solar arrays require more than double the incentive needed to support customer-owned solar arrays.  Not only do leasing companies require more revenue, but customers of leasing companies get less than solar owners, because they presumably sign contracts for electricity that are less than the net metering they would receive in owning a solar array.

Why Does Solar Leasing Cost More?

In the words of the report authors, “these transactions often require attracting additional tax-motivated parties to the project financing, and at considerable expense for transaction and capital.”  How much more expensive?  A host-owned solar array is expected to get financing at 4 percent interest and have a return on equity expectation of 4 percent.  A solar leasing company is expected to pay 6 percent interest on shorter-term debt and to require 15 percent return on equity.

It might seem convenient to blame solar leasing companies for this problem, but they’re merely opportunists in a poor policy environment.  Making your money back on solar in America is complicated.  It requires a combination of tax savvy, skilled navigation of state bureaucracies, persistence at a local permitting office and limited options for low-cost financing. Compared to Germany, with a simple, no-nonsense long-term contract that permits low financing costs and broad participation, America’s solar market is a joke (and the installed cost of solar is much higher as a result).

Furthermore, big banks have also played a role in inflating solar leasing costs to taxpayers, using a legal loophole to collect tax incentives based on (higher) estimated costs of solar installations instead of actual costs.  Leasing company SolarCity was notably targeted by the Treasury Department for its participation in the practice.

Paying Twice for Poor Policy

In other words, we pay twice for bad solar policy in America.  Complicated tax incentive, interconnection, and contract policy makes solar cost more to install than in mature markets like Germany. Solar leasing middlemen simplify the complications, but at a price premium to (complicated) individual ownership.

Even though sunshine is free, no kind of solar power is a free lunch.

John Farrell

About John

John Farrell directs the Energy Self-Reliant States and Communities program at ILSR and he focuses on energy policy developments that best expand the benefits of local ownership and dispersed generation of renewable energy. His latest paper, Democratizing the Electricity System, describes how to blast the roadblocks to distributed renewable energy generation, and how such small-scale renewable energy projects are the key to the biggest strides in renewable energy development. Farrell also authored the landmark report Energy Self-Reliant States, which serves as the definitive energy atlas for the United States, detailing the state-by-state renewable electricity generation potential. Farrell regularly provides discussion and analysis of distributed renewable energy policy on his blog, Energy Self-Reliant States (energyselfreliantstates.org), and articles are regularly syndicated on Grist and Renewable Energy World. John Farrell can also be found on Twitter @johnffarrell, or at jfarrell@ilsr.org.

Indiana Governor Pence Names IURC Chairman Jim Atterholt as New Chief of Staff

Posted by Laura Arnold  /   May 13, 2014  /   Posted in Uncategorized  /   No Comments

 Jim Atterholt

Indianapolis – Governor Mike Pence today named Jim Atterholt as his Chief of Staff, effective Monday, May 19. Atterholt brings extensive state government experience to the position, having served two terms as a state representative and led two state agencies. He currently chairs the Indiana Utility Regulatory Commission (IURC).

“Jim Atterholt’s experience in state government and in the Indiana General Assembly, along with his reputation for integrity make him uniquely qualified to serve as my Chief of Staff,” said Governor Pence. “We look forward to having him join our team, and know he will serve the people of Indiana well.”

Atterholt was appointed by Governor Mitch Daniels to the Indiana Utility Regulatory Commission in June of 2009 and was named chairman in October 5, 2010. He was reappointed in March 2013 for a full term by Governor Pence. Prior to joining the Commission, he was the State Insurance Commissioner for more than four years, where he also served as a member of the Governor’s Cabinet.

Atterholt has dedicated much of his life to public service. He was elected and served two terms as a member of the Indiana General Assembly from 1998 to 2002. As a state representative, he served on the House Commerce, Economic Development and Technology Committee. Atterholt also was a member of the Environmental Affairs Committee, as well as the Labor Committee. Before returning to public service as the State Insurance Commissioner, Atterholt worked as Director of Government Affairs for AT&T-Indiana from 2003 to 2004.

A native of Fort Wayne, Indiana, Atterholt received his bachelor’s degree from the University of Wisconsin in 1986. He has also worked as Chief of Staff in Washington, D.C., and later as District Director in Indiana for a member of the United States Congress. He also serves on the board of directors of the Saint Florian Center for at-risk children.

“It has been a blessing to observe the positive tone Governor Pence and his team have set for Indiana and their commitment to servant leadership,” said Atterholt. “The Governor has a heart for all Hoosiers and a well-deserved reputation for showing kindness to even those who may disagree. I am honored to serve in this new role.”

Atterholt and his wife Brenda have three children and reside in Indianapolis.

Contact Information:
Name: Kara Brooks
Phone: 317-232-1622
Email: kbrooks@gov.in.gov

This additional information can be found on Jim Atterholt's LinkedIn profile:

Chairman

Indiana Utility Regulatory Commission

Serve as a member of the National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissioners (NARUC) and its Committee on Natural Gas

Commissioner

Indiana Department of Insurance

Served as a member of the Governor's Cabinet and represented Indiana as a member of the National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Director of Government Affairs

AT&T Indiana

State Representative

Indiana General Assembly

Served on the Environmental Affairs Committee, the Labor Committee, and the House Commerce, Economic Development, and Technology Committee, which has jurisdiction over all utility-related legislation

Chief of Staff/District Director

Fifth Congressional District

Washington DC and Indianapolis. Served first in the DC office and later in the Indiana district office in various roles including Chief of Staff and District Director

Education

University of Wisconsin-Madison

University of Wisconsin-Madison

Bachelor of Arts (B.A.), Political Science and History

Activities and Societies: Member of Beta Theta Pi Fraturnity

Bill to freeze Ohio’s renewable energy standards passes Senate: How they voted on SB 310

Posted by Laura Arnold  /   May 13, 2014  /   Posted in Uncategorized  /   No Comments

statehouse2.jpg

The Ohio Senate stayed late into the early morning last week to pass a bill freezing Ohio's renewable energy laws. Kiichiro Sato, Associated Press, File

By Jackie Borchardt, Northeast Ohio Media Group 
Email the author | Follow on Twitter

on May 12, 2014 at 1:25 PM, updated May 12, 2014 at 1:45 PM

COLUMBUS, Ohio -- A few lawmakers crossed party lines when the Ohio Senate voted Thursday to advance a freeze on Ohio's renewable energy laws.

Senate Bill 310 freezes for two years a 2008 state law requiring utility companies to sell more electricity from renewable sources of energy and requires a committee to study the effects of the renewable energy standards.

The bill also allows companies to look outside of Ohio for more than 50 percent of the energy needed to meet those requirements and makes it easier for companies to opt out of energy efficiency programs.

The bill is the product of months of debate in the Senate, which began with a proposal to end the requirements altogether.

The bill cleared the chamber just after 1 a.m. Thursday in a 21-12 vote, with three Republicans and one Democrat voting against their parties. Sen. Bill Beagle, a Tipp City Republican; Sen. Randy Gardner, a Bowling Green Republican and Sen. Gayle Manning, a North Ridgeville Republican, voted against the bill while Sen. Shirley Smith, a Cleveland Democrat, voted for the bill.

The version passed by the GOP-controlled Senate also had the support of Republican Gov. John Kasich. In a joint statement with Senate President Keith Faber, a Celina Republican, Kasich said the 2008 mandate is "a challenge to job creation and Ohio's economic recovery.

"They are simply unrealistic and will drive up energy costs for job creators and consumers," the statement continues. "However, alternative energy sources are an important component of Ohio's diverse energy portfolio, which is why we've rejected the notion of scrapping Ohio's renewable standards."

The bill is being considered in the House.

See how your lawmaker voted on SB 310 below. Don't know who represents you in Columbus? Find your district here.

Read the full versions and summaries of the bill on the Legislative Service Commission website.

SB 310 Freeze state renewable energy standards.

Greater Cleveland delegation
Senator Party Hometown Vote
Eklund, John Rep. Munson Twp. Yes
LaRose, Frank Rep. Copley Yes
Manning, Gayle Rep. North Ridgeville No
Obhof, Larry Rep. Medina Yes
Patton, Tom Rep. Strongsville Yes
Sawyer, Tom Dem. Akron No
Skindell, Michael Dem. Lakewood No
Smith, Shirley Dem. Cleveland Yes
Turner, Nina Dem. Cleveland No
Balance of the state
Bacon, Kevin Rep. Worthington Yes
Balderson, Troy Rep. Zanesville Yes
Beagle, Bill Rep. Tipp City No
Brown, Edna Dem. Toledo No
Burke, David Rep. Marysville Yes
Cafaro, Capri Dem. Hubbard No
Coley, Bill Rep. Liberty Twp. Yes
Faber, Keith Rep. Celina Yes
Gardner, Randy Rep. Bowling Green No
Gentile, Lou Dem. Steubenville No
Hite, Cliff Rep. Findlay Yes
Hughes, Jim Rep. Columbus Yes
Jones, Shannon Rep. Springboro Yes
Jordan, Kris Rep. Powell Yes
Kearney, Eric Dem. Cincinnati No
Lehner, Peggy Rep. Kettering Yes
Oelslager, Scott Rep. North Canton Yes
Peterson, Bob Rep. Sabina Yes
Schaffer, Tim Rep. Lancaster Yes
Schiavoni, Joe Dem. Boardman No
Seitz, Bill Rep. Cincinnati Yes
Tavares, Charleta Dem. Columbus No
Uecker, Joe Rep. Miami Twp. Yes
Widener, Chris Rep. Springfield Yes

See original story at

http://www.cleveland.com/open/index.ssf/2014/05/bill_to_freeze_ohios_renewable.html 
 

I&M VP Marc Lewis to talk to Michigan LWV members about “The Grid”

Posted by Laura Arnold  /   May 13, 2014  /   Posted in Indiana Michigan Power Company (I&M), Uncategorized  /   No Comments

LWV logo

LEAGUE OF WOMEN VOTERS®
OF BERRIEN AND CASS COUNTIES, MICHIGAN

League of Women Voters to discuss The Grid

Posted: Saturday, May 10, 2014 11:45 pm

BUCHANAN — The League of Women Voters of Berrien and Cass Counties and American Electric Power (AEP)/Indiana Michigan Power (I &M) are sponsoring a presentation on The Grid at 6 p.m. Tuesday at the AEP/Cook administrative building, 500 Circle Drive, Buchanan, north of the city center on the bluff overlooking the St. Joseph River. Coming from the Indiana Michigan Power Co.’s Fort Wayne office to speak are Marc Lewis, vice president of Regulatory and External Affairs, and Archie Pugh, managing director for AEP Transmission Services.

The electric grid reliably supplies the area with all its power, except when it doesn’t, as with storms, malfunctions, etc. How reliable is the electric distribution system? Is it flexible enough to work with alternative energy sources? How secure is it? Who owns and maintains the grid? Is it regulated? And who plans for its future? There will be an opportunity for questions from the audience.

This meeting is open to the public and there is no charge. For more information on the League and its activities, go to lwvbcc.org and visit us on Facebook.

Copyright 2013 IndianaDG